HOF Talk: Mike Campbell

[Jwalk100]

I'm not sure what the argument against him is other than "it doesn't feel right in my gut". All the numbers are there to reach the various counting stat and rate stat thresholds even if they aren't top half of the HoF.

For me, it's the gut feeling.

Your guts smell like shit.

[recte44]

I'm not sure what the argument against him is other than "it doesn't feel right in my gut". All the numbers are there to reach the various counting stat and rate stat thresholds even if they aren't top half of the HoF.

For me, it's the gut feeling.

Your guys smell like shit.

[JimSlade]

Funny, Campbell was a no-brainer Yes for me. I guess it helped that I didn't know him in the context of other players at his position in his time. Whenever I think about HoF candidates, I do tend to think, "Was he in the Top 2 at his position?" I didn't consider that for Campbell. I thought his surface numbers were strong.

[Trebro]

I do not care about their peers as much as I care about the player and what he did. Neither the black or grey indexes are very important to me..Which is why Campbell is a clear yes for me.