I'm glad I didn't offend you, because I'm truly glad to see you putting energy into making up players!! But like Odie, I'd like to see the effort put to creatively inventing players.c-mitch wrote:I'm not irritated, but I suppose I was of the mind that this league had quite a few "real" people in it since my team had at least 3, and maybe more. But I tried to select guys that were more or less b-list style celebs, kinda under the radar, at least in the cases of Screech and Boston Rob.elligator wrote:At the risk of irritating some people who are working hard to create amateurs, are we perhaps going a little overboard on the celebrities? I'd like to see some more made up people. I get the feeling that it's players like the Nebraska brothers that make this league great, not having N*Sync in your infield. In my opinion, a few celebrities (1 to 3) is cool in any given year, but I don't want this league to become an IMDB database.
Maybe Kid Rock is too high profile, but no more so that Tim McGraw - though I do get his real-life connection to baseball. Kid Rock is a big Tiger fan, which is well known in Detroit.
Honestly, I haven't looked over the other teams in depth, other than spotting Rob Dibble somewhere.
I'm also not really educated on some of the league's history and/or mythology with these made-up players...like the Nebraskas.
Being new, I'm just kinda trying to feel my way along and contribute where I can.
edit: My apologies as well, because when I made Screech, I had no idea that Zack Morris, aka This Guy, was already on the roster of my AAA team. I never would have created him had I seen that.
That's too bad, because Screech was the one guy I kind of liked! I think the former MLB defectors are considered separate from the Ammy's we make up.
I just reviewed my team. I have 3 former Major Leaguers on my big league roster: Sean Berry, Hipolito Pichardo, and some Cub I don't remember named Kevin Foster. I have zero "real" people from outside of baseball.
Looking in my minors, I have Nasir "Nasty Nas" Jones in AAA, whom I'm proud to say will never see my big league team. Mackey Sasser and Olmedo Saenz are in AA, along with Malcolm "Mal" Reynolds who evidently found the MBBA to be a good place to hide from the Reavers. That's it, I think. So that's two "real or fictional" non-baseball people on my team, with 5 former MLBers. Of those, only Mal is likely to make it to the majors.
I still advocate my original vote of 1 to 3 total per year real celebrities.