Wow, breaking some new ground there was the "Master Plan"TM. But unlike the financial and pitching situations, where Portland did pretty well in regards to the "Master Plan"TM, the organization took a hard turn away from their plan to play solid defense.Defense:
Play it really good. Like, everywhere. All positions.
Granted, early on the organization stuck to the script. Several guys in the Portland lineup were superb fielders. Some of those guys, like Miguel Cortez and Arthur Daniel still remain on the squad. The club traded for Robert Menzies who is one of the top hitting and fielding shortstops in the league. Throw in Pedro Gomez behind the dish and Myeong-hwan Kim in the corner outfield and you have the makings of a well rounded group.
So you'd think, with those guys mentioned above the organization was doing things right according to the "Master Plan"TM. But if that were the case, how do you explain the fact the team currently has 3 guys who are best suited as DHs out there playing defense. Well, two of them are trying to field a ball while one of them is the DH. Manuel Martinez, Bartolo Ortiz, and Werner McConnell, Jr couldn't field their way out of a paper bag if they had to yet two of those guys are stuck playing 1B and, god forbid, a corner outfield spot regularly with the club. And let us not forget that Juan Mendoza has the range and the reach of a T-Rex over at 3B. These guys are all poorly suited to play defense for a team that truly wants to start contending. With that said, the defense grade for the "Master Plan"TM portion comes in at a putrid D-.
To make matters worse for Portland, these guys also tie in to the lower grade for the Financial portion as well. The bottom 4 names on that list (Martinez, Ortiz, McConnel, and Mendoza) are all set to make $44.5 million in 2044 and then $43.1 million in 2045. It is not until after the 2045 season that any of these guys can potentially come off the books with either expiring contracts or possibly player or team options.
It may be tough, but the Portland front office needs to re-examine this defense moving forward!