2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

jcrmoon42 · Post by **jcrmoon42** » Mon Sep 09, 2013 4:24 pm

7teen wrote:I went back and looked it up... Gunga received 466 points and since the league resumed on this forum, that is the fewest number of points any Hall of Famer has received thus far. In fact, we've had players get more votes and not get in. And Gunga actually had years of more points and NOT get in based off the standards.

That is as much a function of the number of ballots as it is the quality of the player. Can't glean too much from that number. Might have been a year with little ballot interest.

jcrmoon42 · Post by **jcrmoon42** » Mon Sep 09, 2013 4:58 pm

Going to be some great names left off the next ballot. I've already dumped the last five guys from last year's ballot.

JimBob2232 · Post by **JimBob2232** » Mon Sep 09, 2013 5:17 pm

Unfortunately that is the way its gotta be....

7teen · Post by **7teen** » Tue Sep 10, 2013 8:13 am

jcrmoon42 wrote:
7teen wrote:
bschr682 wrote:But there will be an Egan award someday......
The JL Silk Award should go ahead and be re-named the Puckett Award.
I don't know about that. Bopper Kengos has a heck of an argument too. By the time he's done, the career record book will be nearly untouchable.

Hard to deny that, but Puckett has claimed 7 Silk Awards to Kengos' 2 or 3. Id have to look up the official number for Kengos.

agrudez · Post by **agrudez** » Tue Sep 10, 2013 9:06 am

7teen wrote:Hard to deny that, but Puckett has claimed 7 Silk Awards to Kengos' 2 or 3. Id have to look up the official number for Kengos.

Kengos will have the sexy counting stats that the HOF likes to see, but there is absolutely no doubt that Puckett was the better of the two... a career 172 OPS+... truly other-wordly.

jcrmoon42 · Post by **jcrmoon42** » Tue Sep 10, 2013 11:46 am

agrudez wrote:
7teen wrote:Hard to deny that, but Puckett has claimed 7 Silk Awards to Kengos' 2 or 3. Id have to look up the official number for Kengos.
Kengos will have the sexy counting stats that the HOF likes to see, but there is absolutely no doubt that Puckett was the better of the two... a career 172 OPS+... truly other-wordly.

No question about that. There has to be some credit for an awesome name as well. For years, we've enjoyed giving away the Silk Trophy. Would you rather win a Puckett Trophy or a Bopper Trophy?

agrudez · Post by **agrudez** » Tue Sep 10, 2013 12:29 pm

jcrmoon42 wrote:No question about that. There has to be some credit for an awesome name as well. For years, we've enjoyed giving away the Silk Trophy. Would you rather win a Puckett Trophy or a Bopper Trophy?

What about 'The Cricket' award?

7teen · Post by **7teen** » Tue Sep 10, 2013 7:03 pm

jcrmoon42 wrote:
agrudez wrote:
7teen wrote:Hard to deny that, but Puckett has claimed 7 Silk Awards to Kengos' 2 or 3. Id have to look up the official number for Kengos.
Kengos will have the sexy counting stats that the HOF likes to see, but there is absolutely no doubt that Puckett was the better of the two... a career 172 OPS+... truly other-wordly.
No question about that. There has to be some credit for an awesome name as well. For years, we've enjoyed giving away the Silk Trophy. Would you rather win a Puckett Trophy or a Bopper Trophy?

Good Grief!! Moonie has turned into HAROLD "FREAKING" REYNOLDS!!!

The Brewster

The Brewster

2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Re: 2011 Hall of Fame Final Tally

Who is online