Page 1 of 1

2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Wed Jun 19, 2019 7:02 pm
by RonCo
As always PLEASE SEND YES VOTES to Matt.
Effective immediately, Hall of Fame voting is open. The process will proceed as follows:

1) Players eligible for inclusion this year are listed below. (Note: the "Veterans Committee" may add up to two additional nominees per year).
2) Full conversations about each player can be found in that player's "Discussion Thread" elsewhere on the forum. (linked to each name)
3) Each BBA GM is expected to copy the ballot, and indicate which of those players they would vote in. This is a straight yes/no vote for each candidate. There is no limit to the number of candidates you can vote for.
4) That ballot will be PMed (or emailed) to the commissioner (recte44) prior to Spring Training Sim #1.
5) The commissioner will compile the votes, and release final results (preferably in the Media Guide)
6) Any candidate who received 75% or more of cast votes will be inducted.
7) Any candidate who receives 10% or less of cast votes will be permanently removed from ballot
8) Any candidate who is not inducted after being on the ballot for 7 years will be permanently removed.

Here is a link to the ballot:

And here's a text block of the basics:

Code: Select all

NAME	Yrs Left on Ballot	TM	POS	YRS	JAWS	WAR	HOF STD avg 53	HOF MON avg 126	BLK INK avg 23	GRY INK avg 109
Boone Carlyle	3	LOU	3B	19	51.6	65.9	44	56	0	51
Eduardo Lopez	4	IND	SP	15	58.9	62.2	48	48	32	193
Enrique Gomez	7	OMA	SP	17	67.7	88.7	54	189	37	177
Mike Love	3	HFX	LF	19	56.6	72.6	37	64	11	69
Ricardo Diaz	7	CAL	SP	20	78.8	88.9	52	228	68	265
Chris Workman	7	HNT	2B	18	45.7	55.7	46	54	10	76
Juan Jose Ornelas	4	BIR	SP	15	57.7	65.4	37	124	22	182
Bob Sanderson	7	HNT	CL	16	17.3	17.6	57	131	2	68
Diego Moreno	4	BIR	3B	17	55.6	70.3	42	68	4	58
Jose Cavazos	7	HNT	SP	20	44.9	60.0	30	52	8	104
Mario Gonzalez	7	LOU	SP	18	39.7	51.4	27	50	1	75
Rafael Bido	2	ATC	1B	14	43.5	51.5	44	110	27	139
Kal "Man of Steel" El	2	BIR	CF	18	52.8	64.7	52	93	7	88
Cris Vazquez	7	CAL	1B	17	13.4	13.2	21	57	9	109
Lewis Stephens	7	NSV	C	16	48.1	60.4	48	117	0	54
Lionel Sanguinacco	3	HAW	RP	16	18.3	23.7	65	114	8	69
Sergio Ramos	7	OMA	RF	14	26.7	29.1	53	128	4	78
Juan Pablo	4	MEX	2B	16	50.4	61.6	51	61	0	116
Brett Caves	VET	BRK	CF	13	52.9	59.0	54	59	0	59
Braggo Franco	VET	HNT	SP	16	58.5	91.1	38	48	0	0
Finally, a listing of all candidates, how long they've been on the ballot, and % yes votes each season...

2039-HoF-Class.PNG
2039-HoF-Class.PNG (20.27 KiB) Viewed 424 times

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Thu Jun 20, 2019 2:47 am
by usnspecialist
For the new guys, the reason anyone before 2036 has an X for that year is we did a ranking based system.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:00 am
by Rubaboo
Hmmmm... According to the spreadsheet, Ricardo Diaz has a career FIP of 33.3. Doesn't really seem Hall worthy to me... #Gomezwasbetter

*ducks*

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:30 am
by niles08
Well, that was an easy class. Only 2 clear yes votes from me so that's all I put down.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:54 am
by RonCo
Rubaboo wrote:
Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:00 am
Hmmmm... According to the spreadsheet, Ricardo Diaz has a career FIP of 33.3. Doesn't really seem Hall worthy to me... #Gomezwasbetter

*ducks*
Oops...fixed

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Thu Jun 20, 2019 9:12 am
by Lane
niles08 wrote:
Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:30 am
Well, that was an easy class. Only 2 clear yes votes from me so that's all I put down.
hmph. interesting.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Sun Jun 23, 2019 1:23 pm
by RonCo
Bump as a reminder.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:17 pm
by elkcat
how do folks usually vote? high score board or history museum?

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:24 pm
by recte44
Still need a bunch of votes

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:26 pm
by RonCo
elkcat wrote:
Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:17 pm
how do folks usually vote? high score board or history museum?
Like mot groups of guys, we have an opinionated mish-mash. Reading some of the discussion threads will give an idea of how some folks think.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:53 pm
by usnspecialist
got mine in, and yes we have a decided mix of big hall and small hall guys.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 1:54 pm
by Spiccoli
Lane wrote:
Thu Jun 20, 2019 9:12 am
niles08 wrote:
Thu Jun 20, 2019 8:30 am
Well, that was an easy class. Only 2 clear yes votes from me so that's all I put down.
hmph. interesting.
Yeah... Didn't necessarily agreed with that sentiment. I think there's two no brainers, but that didn't mean they were the only two who deserved votes.

Re: 2039 Hall of Fame Ballot, Rules, and Voting Chatter

Posted: Mon Jun 24, 2019 2:50 pm
by Rubaboo
Ok, who didn't vote for Gomez? The 'Always Second Place to Diaz' thing could've been set aside long enough to make them both unanimous you know...

...on second thought, it was probably Ted. I considered voting no on Diaz for a second to let Gomez win one but couldn't actually bring myself to do it. Morals and karma and integrity and all that.