61.085 – Prospect Watch – Catchers

GM: Ron Collins

Moderator: RonCo

User avatar
RonCo
GB: JL Frontier Division Director
Posts: 22118
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2015 10:48 pm
Has thanked: 2435 times
Been thanked: 3965 times

61.085 – Prospect Watch – Catchers

Post by RonCo » Wed Dec 25, 2024 1:58 pm

Image
Off Topic
2061 Season Snapshot


When I stepped into the role as Bikini’s GM, backstop was such a position of need I went out and Rule 5ed five “glove only” guys and went into the season with two of them as my “starters.” There’s a reason I drafted Pedro Jimenez that year. I was a low ceiling, high floor guy who was already developed enough that we brough him to the bigs before that season was out.

Needless to say, stocking catchers became a focus.

Which brings us to today. Looking at the organization feels considerably better overall. To be certain, we don’t have superstars coming through the ranks, but as Jimenez turns 28, we have five guys who I think are interesting and who look like they can make an impact at the major league level at some point. The first two I think are fairly certain to see a BBA field sometime, and the other three are all interesting question marks.

So, let’s take a look at them, shall we?


#1Ivan Quintana
Ivan Quintana (C)AgeOVRCONBABIPAvKGAPPOWEYE
Level: AAA2035/405/55/56/65/56/65/5
Age: 20*IFRIFEIFATDPOFROFEOFA
Bats-Throws: L/R*2351335
Height: 6'3"*SPDAGRSTERUNCBKCFRCAR
Weight: 195*2112666
Source: DR60.5
Quintana carries a 40 Overall Potential, and I think it’s that low due to defensive blandness. Offensively there’s a lot to like, starting from the fact that he’s a lefthanded bat who doesn’t have any holes, including the fact that he can hit lefties some, which makes him a real candidate for a backup role if nothing else. He’s been a solid OBP guy who puts up positive OPS+ numbers. His arm is actually stronger than Jimenez’s, but his blocking and framing need work. At age 20, he’s got some time. We’ll see if the team wants to devote a slot on Pain Island to work on those.

Regardless, Quintana is the kind of OOTP player I love to have around because I personally think that “40” looks like an under-rating. Nothing is more fun than having a 40 or 45 play like a 50 or 55.

Fingers crossed.


2062 Projection: Hopefully will back up Jimenez


#2Rahimat Sulayman
Rahimat Sulayman (C)AgeOVRCONBABIPAvKGAPPOWEYE
Level: A2030/355/55/55/55/54/55/5
Age: 20*IFRIFEIFATDPOFROFEOFA
Bats-Throws: R/R*3371617
Height: 6'1"*SPDAGRSTERUNCBKCFRCAR
Weight: 200*2232779
Source: DR60.3
Sulayman has taken an overall rating downgrade since being drafted in 2060 (his power potential dropped from “6” to “5,” but I’m not particularly worried about that right now. His bat has been strong enough (5 homers, .287/.369/.373) at Lake City A-Ball, and his glove is still looking a bit better than workable. The arm is among the best in the organization.

I am optimistic that the power hit will return. I suppose it’s possible we could send a few PPT his way and see what happens. At 20, though, he’s in that “Wait and see what happens” period. My brain projects him as a solid minimum salary backup as it stands today, but he’s not far off a stronger role.


2062 Projection: Current thought is he’ll play all of 2062 in AA Kamloops


#3David Castillo
David Castillo (C)AgeOVRCONBABIPAvKGAPPOWEYE
Level: A1920/454/84/76/84/54/53/3
Age: 19*IFRIFEIFATDPOFROFEOFA
Bats-Throws: L/R*3431222
Height: 6'5"*SPDAGRSTERUNCBKCFRCAR
Weight: 195*2311554
Source: DR59.2S
I have it on good word from other GMs that David Castillo is “not a catcher.” I can see why they say that. The 5/5/4 defensive ratings score him out as just barely more capable than a cement block with a strike zone painted on it. Fair enough. What David Castillo is projected to be able to do, though, is bat left handed and hit about anything thrown at him. The ratings have been growing, which is good…but we drafted him as a really, really young kid out of high school, so the numbers have been sporadic. His .268/.328/.332 in Short-A Port au Prince this year were encouraging at moments.

To be honest, I think his path to the majors is more dependent upon developing better plate discipline than anything about the glove. If he completely busts out there, he can play for me the same way Aaron Stone played for me in my days with Yellow Springs.

We sent him to the Dev Lab last year, and the glove edged up. I expect we’ll do it again this year. If things go well for him, there’s anonzero chance David Castillo will not only “be a catcher,” but might be one of the better ones in the game. Time will tell, though. Until then, we can dream.


2062 Projection: A Full Season with our Lake City A-Ball team


#4Takiji Takata
Takiji Takata (C)AgeOVRCONBABIPAvKGAPPOWEYE
Level: R1920/302/42/43/53/32/23/4
Age: 19*IFRIFEIFATDPOFROFEOFA
Bats-Throws: S/R*3241524
Height: 6'2"*SPDAGRSTERUNCBKCFRCAR
Weight: 183*121110105
Source: DR59.4
Consider him the anti-David Castillo. The guy could already be a major league defender, but his bat is about as nonexistent as you can get. When I drafted him back in 2059 (round 4), I decided I’d just drop him into R-Ball and if nothing else he would help our pitchers there. I’m sure this has been true. I was also hoping his high marks for Work Ethic and Intelligence might see the offensive skills tick up. I’m about equally sure this has not been true.

At 19 and as a switch hitter, though, he remains a person of interest.


2062 Projection: Depends on other draftees. Either a 4th course of Rookie Ball, or a move to Short A.


#5Fred Adamic
Fred Adamic (C)AgeOVRCONBABIPAvKGAPPOWEYE
Level: SA2120/253/43/43/53/33/34/5
Age: 21*IFRIFEIFATDPOFROFEOFA
Bats-Throws: R/R*4251545
Height: 6'2"*SPDAGRSTERUNCBKCFRCAR
Weight: 200*1112996
Source: MLC
Adamic is another guy who is here for the glove. Unlike Takata, though, if he’s going to make it the show, the glove isn’t big enough to rely on by itself. So he’s going to need a serious bump. Two would be better. Still, there’s enough material here to make a list.


2062 Projection: We picked him up partway through the year, and had him serve a backup role. Depending on some other decisions, I think he’d benefit from a full season as a starter in Short A, though I could see him at A-Ball if playing time of others warrants it.
GM: Bikini Krill
Nothing Matters But the Pacific Pennant
Roster

User avatar
BaseClogger
BBA GM
Posts: 3373
Joined: Sun May 08, 2022 8:55 am
Has thanked: 3048 times
Been thanked: 817 times

Re: 61.085 – Prospect Watch – Catchers

Post by BaseClogger » Wed Dec 25, 2024 5:00 pm

I remain more lukewarm on these guys than you. The guys with loud tools have significant warts and vice-verse. I’ll be following along to learn what I have wrong.
San Fernando Bears GM since 2051

User avatar
RonCo
GB: JL Frontier Division Director
Posts: 22118
Joined: Sat Nov 14, 2015 10:48 pm
Has thanked: 2435 times
Been thanked: 3965 times

Re: 61.085 – Prospect Watch – Catchers

Post by RonCo » Wed Dec 25, 2024 5:36 pm

I wouldn't say you're wrong, though I suppose we could be looking at things through different lenses. I do expect Quintana and Sulayman will see time in the majors, but I'm not betting on how much time, yet. the other three need help to make it, but Castillo in particular has a very high ceiling if he gets that help.

My goal in building a farm system is to layer it with players who have respectable opportunity fields. That was, eventually something can happen.
GM: Bikini Krill
Nothing Matters But the Pacific Pennant
Roster

Post Reply Previous topicNext topic

Return to “Bikini Krill”

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest