2057, BBA All-Star Voting Chatter

[recte44]

All-Star Voting OPEN, due by Tuesday 4pm Central: https://statsplus.net/brewster/awards/? ... lotcurrent

[BaseClogger]

Frick League RF is an interesting decision. Licht and Kidd are having very similar seasons.

[Jwalk100]

My votes



Johnson League

C Claudio Morgan LV
1B Larry Stinson CLG
2B Dave Ackerman CCJ
3B Eduardo Gonzalez MTL
SS Qutuz Mahdi BOI/MTL
LF Andrew Wright PHX
CF Felix Roman MEX
RF Kazunari Chikafuji CCJ
DH Banger Dan RMO

SP Hector Silva CCJ
SP Vassilis Zorba MEX
SP Carlos Olivas MEX
SP Juan Marroquin JAX
SP Kinzo Iwamoto MTL

RP Alejandro Chavez JAX
RP Tom Miller MTL
RP Max Birstall MTL
RP Renato Lacerda EDM
RP Slawomir Trzcinski NO



Frick League

C Davenport Hinkle VAN
1B Wafid Bishr NSH
2B Colby Triska NSH
3B Luis Mendoza OMA
SS Steveland Morris LBC
LF Juan Rivera NSH
CF Crissy Tingle NSH
RF Dane Licht TWC
DH Fernando Castillo LBC

SP Robert Hanson SAC
SP Eric Stevens NSH
SP Phil Cole VAN
SP Carlos Flores SAC
SP Barney Lindsey NSH

RP Quirke Roddis NSH
RP Ludwig Werberg SAC
RP Jim Achbar SFB
RP Fernando Villarreal VAL
RP Gerald Rogers YS9

[Trebro]

Rogers was my first RP convert and he's been amazing. Thanks for the vote!

[chicoruiz]

Interesting to see what criteria folks use to vote for relievers. I look at who has the most saves plus wins minus losses. Then I try to include at least one guy who has a lot of “holds” and a good WHIP, and another guy who has pitched a ton of innings in relief and done well.

I can never find blown saves on stats+. Am I just not looking in the right place?

[BaseClogger]

I mostly use WAR for position players. If a few players are within ~0.5 WAR I'll consider a guy with significantly higher WAR per PA.

For pitchers I still sort by WAR but there's usually a lot of players grouped together and I pick the lowest ERAs from that group.

[recte44]

Still need to finish voting (for BBA):
https://statsplus.net/brewster/awards/? ... lotcurrent

BIK
RMO
YS9
OMA
LOU
MAD (JL)
JAX

GBC:
LON
JER
SYD
SAO
BUE
TOK

[Lane]

Interesting to see what criteria folks use to vote for relievers. I look at who has the most saves plus wins minus losses. Then I try to include at least one guy who has a lot of “holds” and a good WHIP, and another guy who has pitched a ton of innings in relief and done well.

I can never find blown saves on stats+. Am I just not looking in the right place?

for relievers i never look at saves...i'll pick the top couple in WAR, then look at the top in FIP and K's and K% while trying to select high usage guys over low usage guys.

[bcslouck]

Interesting to see what criteria folks use to vote for relievers. I look at who has the most saves plus wins minus losses. Then I try to include at least one guy who has a lot of “holds” and a good WHIP, and another guy who has pitched a ton of innings in relief and done well.

I can never find blown saves on stats+. Am I just not looking in the right place?

for relievers i never look at saves...i'll pick the top couple in WAR, then look at the top in FIP and K's and K% while trying to select high usage guys over low usage guys.

I look at WPA and WAR. I'll use ERA and FIP too but those are secondary. If someone has an absurd amount of saves, I'll vote them in even if they aren't as good on the other criteria.

[Trebro]

For relief, I give a vote to the top save folks only, then move to holds. shutdowns, etc. WAR as a last resort tiebreaker because I personally dislike the stat, especially in OOTP.

[bcslouck]

For relief, I give a vote to the top save folks only, then move to holds. shutdowns, etc. WAR as a last resort tiebreaker because I personally dislike the stat, especially in OOTP.

WAR definitely isn't an end all be all, but I like it for comparing the same positions. I like WPA more. Usually those guys are the top guys WAR wise anyway, but you did get the ones with less innings but dominate.

[JimSlade]

For relievers, I will reward a high saves total guy or two, but I first look at WAR, WHIP, and ERA. I try to imagine which RPs would give me the least heartburn if they came in for my team.