Would you rather...?

[cheekimonk]

Have 2 4*/5* position players with the rest being AAAA guys. Or would a team of 2*/3* position players perform better?

And pitchers: 2 4*/5* and the rest 2*/3* or every starter/reliever being one of those players?

You can specify positions.

[Dington]

I’ll take the quality. Plus, AAAA players are usually 2-3* players anyway.

[aaronweiner]

Rather have the 4/5* pitchers. Rather have a whole team of 3* hitters. Of course my team is exactly the opposite.

[Fat Nige]

My team is a real example of what happens if you can’t field a decent set of pitchers lol

[njherdfan]

Rather have the 4/5* pitchers. Rather have a whole team of 3* hitters. Of course my team is exactly the opposite.

Agreed

[cheekimonk]

2 4/5* SP as they are streak stoppers. You might have a series where both are struggling, but if they can stay healthy I think they're crucial to avoid subpar Sims